A reviewer's decision is Approve (the artwork can be printed as it is) or Reject (it needs changes). Each decision is recorded with the reviewer, the time and the exact file, and the shop is emailed.
Approve or reject#
- On the proof page, choose Approve or Reject in the header. Both work only on the version the link asks about: switch back to it if you are looking at another one.
- For a multi-page PDF, choose Entire PDF (the default) or One page at a time and a page number. The dialog title and confirmation name exactly what you are approving. Check Your name and Your email. They are filled in when the page already knows you.
- Add a Page comment for a page decision or a General comment for the entire PDF, such as what must change. Comments you pinned on the artwork are part of the review anyway.
- To approve, tick the confirmation: "I have checked the artwork, including its text, colours, dimensions and barcodes, and approve it for production." When the version has comments, the dialog says how many, with Read them, since approving means it is printed as it is.
- Choose Approve entire PDF, Reject entire PDF, Approve page or Request changes (or press ⌘ Enter or Ctrl Enter).
The dialog thanks you, says how many other reviewers still have to decide, and shows the overall status. Your decision and your name then appear under Reviewers on the History tab.
Review page by page#
Open Pages in the review panel, or choose the pages approved counter in the header. The panel works in both Flat and Booklet view, including fullscreen. It shows a numbered grid and a progress count for the exact version this link asks you to review. A two-page PDF is a front and a back, so its pages are named by side, such as "Page 2 · Back" (see Reviewing a proof); each side is still approved on its own.
- Select a page to open it in the viewer. In Booklet view it opens the spread containing that page; the panel names the single page you are deciding on.
- Choose Approve page or Request changes. Check the page number, enter your identity and an optional comment, and confirm. Approval requires a confirmation that applies only to that page.
- Choose Next page to review to continue to a page you have not approved. You can leave and return to the same link: saved decisions stay with the file version.
| Page status | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Needs review | At least one approver has not approved this page. |
| Approved | Every approver on this link has approved this page. |
| Changes requested | At least one approver requested changes to this page. |
Use Show to filter the grid by status. The selected page also shows Your decision, which may differ from its combined status while another reviewer is still checking it. Refresh page approvals reloads decisions made by other reviewers. Status is shown with text and icons as well as colour.
A page approval does not approve the rest of the PDF. Unreviewed pages remain pending, and the whole file becomes approved only when every approver has approved every page. You may change a page decision until the version locks. To finish in one step, choose Approve entire PDF instead…. An entire-file decision replaces all of your earlier page decisions; it does not replace another reviewer's decisions. Changing one page after your own entire-file decision leaves your decisions on the other pages intact, provided the version is still open.
History and notification emails name the page for a page decision and link directly to it. The proof creator receives approved, changes-requested and remaining page counts with every decision or new comment, then a separate completion email when all approvers finish. See History and notifications. A new file version starts a new review; page approvals are never carried across to a changed PDF.
How a link's status is set#
Only approvers count:
- Rejected as soon as any approver rejected;
- Approved when every approver approved;
- Pending otherwise, for example while an invited reviewer hasn't decided yet.
A staged approval follows the same rule one stage at a time, and a stage can be set to pass with a single approval: see Staged approvals.
People who only commented never hold up an approval. Anyone who decides becomes an approver of the link, so on a link without invited reviewers the first entire-file approval, or completion of all pages by the first approver, approves it.
While a link isn't approved, a reviewer can change their mind: deciding again replaces their earlier decision. A rejected link stays open, because a corrected version is usually on its way.
The dashboard combines the links of the latest version: Approved when any link is approved, else Rejected when any link is rejected (see How approvals work).
An approved version locks#
Once any link of a version is approved, decisions close on every link of that version: the Simple, Advanced and 3D links alike. The Approve and Reject buttons disappear and a strip says the artwork is approved and the decision is final (on the other links: that another reviewer already approved it and decisions are closed). Reviewers can still read the proof and add comments.
Decisions also close on every link of a version once a newer version is uploaded (see Artwork versions).
Two reviewers deciding at the same moment are handled one after the other: once one of them approved, the other is told that the version is already approved.
Reset to pending#
A team member can put a link back to pending, for example after an approval by accident, by the wrong person, or when a revised file is coming.
- Open the link while signed in: Open proof on the Approvals page.
- Choose ⋯ → Reset to pending…, or Reset to pending under Reviewers on the History tab.
- Give a Reason if you like. It is kept in the history.
- Choose Reset to pending. A staged approval starts over at its first stage.
What a reset does:
- every whole-file and page decision on that link is cleared and its status is Pending again;
- reviewers who became approvers only by deciding go back to being viewers; invited reviewers stay approvers;
- comments stay as they are;
- the history records "Reset to pending (was approved)" with your name, the reason, the status before and the decisions it cleared.
A reset is per link. If a version is locked because its Advanced link was approved, reset that link to open decisions on the others. Reviewers can then decide again. The API has the same reset (see Approvals API).
Note: Reviewers can't undo their own approval
Once the entire version is approved, its approvals are final for the reviewer. If they approved by mistake, they ask you, and a team member resets it.